Do you prefer to contact us by phone?

Bekijk het overzicht van onze Wanted kantoren op onze contactpagina.

03/10/2026
21/07/2019

A promised result or just your best effort? The difference between an obligation of result and an obligation of means

A promised result or just your best effort?

Your lawyer loses the case. Your new windows leak. A parcel arrives damaged. Can you hold the service provider liable? The answer often depends on one question: did they promise a result, or only to do their best?

Two types of obligations

Since 2023, the Belgian Civil Code expressly defines both concepts (Article 5.72 of the Civil Code):

  • An obligation of means requires the debtor to exercise all the care of a prudent and reasonable person in order to achieve a certain result. The burden of proving the debtor's fault lies with the creditor.
  • An obligation of result requires the debtor to achieve a specific result. If the result is not achieved, the debtor's fault is presumed, unless they prove force majeure.

The key difference: who has to prove what?

  • What is promised? Obligation of means: acting with due care. Obligation of result: a specific outcome.
  • What must the creditor prove? Obligation of means: that the debtor was at fault. Obligation of result: only that the result was not achieved.
  • How can the debtor escape liability? Obligation of means: by showing they acted with due care. Obligation of result: only by proving force majeure.
  • Standard: a prudent and reasonable person in the same circumstances, or the promised result.

The general rule of evidence still applies: whoever claims something must prove the facts on which the claim is based, and whoever claims to be released must prove it (Article 8.4 of the Civil Code). Article 5.72 sets out how that rule applies to contractual obligations.

Practical examples

  • A lawyer generally has an obligation of means: they must prepare and argue your case carefully, but cannot guarantee a win. Missing a deadline, however, is a fault.
  • A doctor usually has an obligation of means: they promise careful treatment, not a cure. For certain specific aspects, the courts may find an obligation of result.
  • A contractor installing windows usually has an obligation of result as to correct installation: the windows must be watertight and work properly.
  • A carrier has an obligation of result to deliver the goods or the passenger safely to their destination.

Is your contract clear?

Does your contract clearly state what you promise and what you do not? Poor wording may lead you, as a service provider, to guarantee a result you never intended to. Wanted Law can rewrite your terms so that they reflect your actual commitment.

How do you know which obligation applies?

The law contains no rule that determines the type of obligation when the contract is silent. It is a matter of interpreting the contract: what did the parties really intend? Courts take into account, among other things:

  • the wording of the contract, such as "we guarantee" versus "we will endeavour";
  • the element of chance: the more uncertain the result, as in litigation or medical treatment, the more likely it is an obligation of means;
  • the role of the creditor: if they must actively cooperate, an obligation of means is more likely;
  • the expertise of the debtor and the customs of the sector.

The parties can also expressly set this out in their contract. That is the best way to avoid disputes.

Force majeure: the way out under an obligation of result

A party that promised a result and fails to achieve it can only be released by proving force majeure: an impossibility not attributable to the debtor to perform the obligation, taking into account the unforeseeable and unavoidable nature of the obstacle (Article 5.226 of the Civil Code). If the impossibility is temporary, performance is suspended. The debtor must notify the creditor within a reasonable time. If the debtor was already in default, the consequences of force majeure are in principle borne by the debtor (Article 5.227 of the Civil Code).

In short: questions and answers

What is the difference between an obligation of result and an obligation of means? Under an obligation of means, the debtor promises the care of a prudent and reasonable person, and the creditor must prove fault. Under an obligation of result, the debtor promises a specific result, and fault is presumed if that result is not achieved, unless force majeure is proven (Article 5.72 of the Civil Code).

Is a lawyer's or doctor's obligation an obligation of result? As a rule, no. Lawyers and doctors usually have an obligation of means: they must act with due care, but cannot guarantee the outcome.

Frequently asked questions

What if the contract does not say which type of obligation applies?
The court then interprets the contract according to the intention of the parties, looking among other things at the wording, the element of chance and the role of the creditor.

Can a service provider always invoke force majeure?
Only if the obstacle was unforeseeable, unavoidable and not attributable to them. They must also notify you in good time.

Under an obligation of means, do I have to prove that the other party did poor work?
Yes. You must show that they did not act as a prudent and reasonable person in the same circumstances would have.

Can I soften an obligation of result in my contract?
Yes, you can expressly provide that you only take on an obligation of means, or limit your liability within the legal limits. Stricter rules apply to such clauses in consumer contracts.

What you promise determines what you are liable for

Wanted Law helps you define that promise precisely, whether you are a service provider or a client. For further support, visit the Wanted Shop.

Related articles

Others also read

Disclaimer

The information on legal topics that you will find in this contribution is purely informative, general discussions and can in no case be considered as legal advice. Wanted Law accepts no liability for any damage that someone may suffer by relying on this information. If you want legal advice, you should contact a qualified lawyer who will advise you based on your personal situation. All blog posts published on the Wanted Law website are written in accordance with Belgian law.

Copyright

Wanted Law holds the exclusive copyright of this website, its design and its entire content. Use of this website, or parts thereof, in any form whatsoever is prohibited without the prior written consent of Wanted Law.

Online shopping in the Wanted Webshop?

Discover the Wanted Webshop!

I book a video consultation with Wanted Law!

Ik boek een videoconsultatie bij Wanted Law!